Insight 02
Air that smells of chlorine. Stinging eyes. Staff with chronic respiratory problems. These are not unavoidable consequences of swimming — they are consequences of inadequate ventilation in indoor facilities.
Chlorinated pool water reacts with organic material from bathers — sweat, skin cells and urine — forming disinfection by-products. The most dangerous for air quality is trichloramine, NCl₃.
The gas is heavier than air. Its molar mass is around 120 against air's 29, so it settles in a layer directly above the water surface — precisely in the breathing zone of both bathers and staff. That property is what makes it a problem indoors, and it is also why the problem disappears outdoors: not because the gas rises, but because there is no room for it to collect in.
Norwegian measurements show concentrations between 58 and 461 µg/m³, against the Nordic Expert Group's recommended limit of 200. Individual measurements in Norwegian pool halls have reached 1,150 µg/m³, more than twice the WHO recommendation of 500. Norway has set no limit value for NCl₃ in air at all.
A point that is often underestimated: chloramine compounds cannot be filtered out of the air. Activated carbon and other filters rapidly lose effectiveness in the warm, humid environment of a pool hall. The contaminated air has to be replaced with fresh outdoor air.
That sounds simple, but in a cold climate it is demanding. Outdoor air varies sharply with season and weather. In winter, air below freezing has to be heated to bathing temperature. In summer, both dehumidification and cooling may be needed. This requires large, complex and energy-hungry air handling units — expensive to buy, expensive to run and expensive to maintain.
Here is the real trap. Norwegian pool halls are deliberately built so that ventilation air is not directed down towards the water surface, because that would increase evaporation and therefore energy use. But down there is exactly where the gas sits. Indoors you must choose between the energy bill and the air the swimmers breathe, and energy wins.
That trade-off does not exist outdoors. There, nobody pays for the air change.
The Norwegian Pool Technical Association is working on new guidelines that will require substantially greater air change above the water surface than applies today. For training pools the proposal amounts to roughly a doubling of the fresh-air requirement — and even with that increase, the requirement would sit at about half of what it would take to reach the WHO recommendation.
For existing facilities that intend to meet the new requirements, this means investing in larger and more powerful ventilation systems. That is rarely easy to fit into buildings that were never dimensioned for it.
For an outdoor pool the whole question disappears. NCl₃ forms just as readily outdoors as indoors — the water chemistry is identical. But the gas is diluted immediately in the open air volume, and even a light breeze is more than enough to bring the concentration down to negligible levels.
This is also why complaints about stinging eyes, respiratory irritation and "chlorine smell" come almost exclusively from indoor facilities. The characteristic smell people associate with chlorine is in fact NCl₃ and other chloramine compounds — not free chlorine, as many believe. An outdoor pool with good water chemistry can smell very little, even at a high chlorine content.
For our facilities it means that tightened ventilation requirements, which will impose considerable costs on indoor facilities in the years ahead, are simply not relevant. A large part of the regulatory complexity, and the costs that come with it, falls away.
SourcesNorwegian Institute of Public Health · Byggforskserien 552.315 (SINTEF) · WHO Guidelines for Safe Recreational-Water Environments · Nordic Expert Group · Norwegian Pool Technical Association and NTNU on air requirements in pool halls.
Each of the four articles takes on a different side of the same calculation.
See all the articles